Today’s homily is going to be slightly different from my usual one. Which means, for one thing, I don’t have an opening question for you. Instead, I want to remind you of a couple homilies I’ve given before. The first one occurred in early June when I talked about mustard seeds. It was, also, the one when I used the “believe it” sign for the Rockets. In my reflection, I said: “faith is knowing something completely without seeing it, without hearing it, or without touching it.”
In my next homily, I began with a question about high school reunions. The gospel focus in that homily was the story of Jesus going back to his hometown and how he could do few miracles because the Nazarenes lacked faith in him, since they were unwilling to change their views about how he had grown up with them. Again, I said the gift of faith is: “to see with more than our eyes, to hear with more than our ears and to touch with more than our fingertips. When we see, hear and touch with our hearts, it is then that we have reached our reunion with the Father, Son and Holy Spirit.”
My reason for recalling these past homilies is because today’s focus is once more on faith. Faith and Eucharist. Faith and the real and abiding presence of Jesus the Christ.
For the last several weeks, we have been listening to the Gospel of John and reflecting on the Eucharist. Three weeks ago, the gospel reading was about the miracle of the multiplication of the loaves and fishes. Two weeks ago, we heard Jesus say: “I, myself, am the bread of life.” We heard those same words last week, along with his claim: “Whoever eats of this bread will live forever.” In today’s continuation, we heard Jesus say: “Those who feed on my flesh and drink my blood have life eternal.” And next week, the final one for this series from John’s Gospel, we will hear how his listeners reacted to his words.
For some of his listeners, these were hard words to accept. Yet, those first Christians, after his death and resurrection, did accept them. They wanted desperately to accept them. They wanted him to be present with them, as he had assured them he would be. Being Jewish, they knew exactly how they could feel his presence among them. They continued to share in their fellowship meals. These first Jewish-Christians had no problem in feeling his presence when they gathered for these fellowship meals. This ability to bring the past into the present was a major part of their culture and tradition. Unfortunately, it is not a ready part of our modern, western culture.
However, back then, every year when they celebrated Passover, every observant Jew knew how to experience the original Exodus event of which Passover was a memorial. Once again, they experienced the fear and awe of the plagues in Egypt, of how the Lord God led them to freedom, of how they turned from him in the desert and how they re-found him at Mount Sinai, of how he led them, step-by-step, to the Promised Land. For them, it was no mere story, no mere re-telling of an ancient tale. Each year they relived this event, when they gathered together for the Passover meal.
In their own fellowship meals, the first Christians, in common with their culture and heritage, were able to feel the real presence of Jesus the Christ there in their midst. With their faith, they were able to see, hear and touch him once more. He was again present in their ritual actions: the action of breaking and eating the bread, the action of taking and drinking the cup. In some mysterious way, these actions brought them together with their Lord and Savior. They were able, with these actions, to partake of his body and blood, the life-giving force of God which could sustain them beyond the death of their human bodies.
But attitudes change. By the Middle Ages, some twelve centuries after the first Christians had experienced the risen Christ in their fellowship meals, European scholars began to focus less on the mystery of actions and more on the physicality of things. Now they began to ask: “How does the bread and wine become the body and blood of Christ?” rather than the question: “What does it mean to share in the life-giving force of our Lord and Savior?”
Just as twentieth century scientists try to measure and weigh everything in an attempt to understand the physics of life, scholastics of the time of Thomas Aquinas, attempted to explain nature in terms of “things” rather than “actions.” However, St Thomas had no knowledge of molecules and atoms, of wavelengths and colliding particles. Instead, he had “essence” and “accidents.”
For him, “essence” was what made a thing really a thing. So, the “essence” of what made a chair, a chair, and a table, a table were important, real-world questions. The observations that one chair was made of wood and another of bronze were merely “accidents.” “Accidents” also included conditions like whether the chair was in the form of one found in the kitchen or one seen in the throne room. On the other hand, what made a chair a chair was its “essence,” its “substance,” its inner “being,” rather than its external appearance.
And, so, it was said by Thomas Aquinas and other scholastics, trying to explain how bread and wine could become the body and blood of Christ, that the accidents, the appearance of the bread and wine, did not change. On the other hand, the essence, the real substance changed. The essence, the substance, the “being,” had become the body and blood of Christ, just as the gospel said. In other words: Transubstantiation had occurred.
This explanation satisfied the scholastics of the Middle Ages. The teaching about transubstantiation became an essential part of the doctrines summarized by the Council of Trent in 1551. This doctrine or teaching is also referenced in paragraph 1376 of the Catechism of the Catholic Church, published in English in June 1994. However, the new catechism does not stop here. References are also made to the Constitution on the Liturgy composed at the Second Vatican Council.
Once more, we are called in these documents to return to the concepts of the first Christians. We are encouraged to return to a time of experiencing Christ in actions and in participation rather than in physical things. Paragraph 7 of the Constitution on the Liturgy reminds us that Christ is truly present in the gathering of the assembly and within the gathered assembly.
Although we can say the Holy Spirit is present in each one of us, no matter where we are, the spirit of the Father and of the Son is present in a special way as we entered the doors of Christ the Good Shepherd thirty minutes ago. Christ is as present right now in this gathering as he was when his disciples gathered together with him for a fellowship meal. Do you believe this – even if no physical measurement would be able to detect his presence?
Christ is as present in the words of the gospel proclaimed twelve minutes ago as he was when he preached to the crowds we heard about in that gospel. Do you believe this – even if no physical measurement would show a change in the sounds you heard?
Christ is as present in the words which will call down the Holy Spirit onto the bread and wine to be brought to this altar, as he was when he blessed and distributed the loaves and fishes. Do you believe this – even if no camera could record the descent of this Spirit?
Christ is as present in the bread and wine we will consume as he was in the flesh we must feed upon, and the blood we must drink in order to have eternal life. Do you believe this – even if the most sophisticated chemical analysis could not reveal a change?
Yet, in some mysterious way that cannot be answered by any question beginning with the word “how,” Christ is really present in each of these actions. Our actions of gathering, of proclaiming and listening, of petitioning and blessing, of taking, eating and drinking. However, there is a way of knowing that he is present. We know of his presence by our own Eucharistic actions.
The mass does not end with either the consecration nor with communion. In fact, the English word “mass” comes from the old Latin expression once heard at the end of each Eucharistic celebration. The last words heard, but not understood, by the peasants of Europe and the rest of us until the mid-1960’s were: “Ita, missa est. Go, you are sent forth.” In the dismissal which completes each Eucharistic celebration, we are instructed: “Go forth, you are commissioned to be the body of Christ.”
Although I did not give you a question to ponder as I began today’s homily, I do have a concluding question for you to reflect upon. When you go forth today from this assembly, will your actions convey to everyone you meet that you possess within you the life-giving force you have consumed, the body and blood of Jesus the Christ?
Twentieth Sunday in Ordinary Time; August 14, 1994
Prv 9:1-6; Eph 5:15-20; Jn 6:51-58