Thus far I’ve made only passing reference to my father, in terms of “he” or “him.” That’s how I always thought of the man as I was growing up – not a relative, not a biological parent, but rather merely a distant male presence in my life, a presence that was somewhat evil, albeit, he was only emotionally, not physically, abusive, even though he often threatened bodily punishment. In return, I hated him. Somehow I did not completely fear him, because I realized, at some level, that he would not actually lay a hand on me. I’m not sure why I thought this. Many times, I believed, as probably many sons do, that he was not really my biological father. I was adopted; I could not truly be related to him. He often reinforced that belief.
His usual war-cry or opening salvo was about money, the money we stole from him. Born of the depression and failed banks, he had no financial accounts of any sort, not even a checking account; he did have US savings bonds (war bonds.) The money available for food was deposited, with the cashing of his paycheck, into a coffee cup on a kitchen shelf. I have no idea where my mother kept any funds for clothing and household needs. Perhaps there was a “cup” in some other part of the house, or she was forced to use what she earned by working in the cashier’s office at the local Woolworth’s.
At random times, often at the beginning of the year, he would yell that we took money from the cup for things other than food. We stole “his” money! This opening cry was frequently followed by abusive language about my mother. In an effort to get my hatred under control, I would write in my diary what had occurred. In most cases I wrote in a code I had invented to conceal thoughts I wanted to keep private.
But not in mid-August and early September of my senior year, 1952.
That summer he had taken violently ill and was hospitalized. I have no recollection of the nature of his illness, since it is recorded in code that I could read easily at the time but which the years have made difficult to decipher. However, the entries for early September appear un-coded as “regular English.”
Monday, September 1, Labor Day: “I suppose I should write today’s entry in code but English will do better. First: about one o’clock, his sister phoned and said to Mom, “What! Haven’t you gone to the hospital yet?” Aunt Mary then added she couldn’t go, for she was canning tomatoes and would be too tired! So when Mom finished washing clothes, she went to the hospital in Warren. No one else was in “his” ward, for Mr. Allen and the Greek had been discharged. Therefore “he” spent his time calling Mom vile names. Today she was a whore, and a cock-sucker who should go out on the road and pick some prick up.
“A few nights ago, when “he” was so sick I asked God to let “him” live, for “he” might have changed and we should wait and see. Well, my most ardent wish now is he has a relapse and suffers in agony before “he” dies. But “he” will probably live making Mom and me exist in a hell on earth.”
Tuesday, September 2: ““He” came home from the hospital today. Uncle Frank Borecki brought him, because “his” relatives were too busy to do it. Mom had to pay a hospital bill of 51¢. Hospitalization took care of the rest. Now he can spend his $800 and bonds in gambling. His mother and brother, Joe, were here to see him. Aunts Vi and Ada phoned.”
Wednesday, September 3: “For some unknown reason, “he” again started degrading Mom, saying she was lazy, a poor housekeeper, stank, etc. The same as usual. “He” seems to be angry because she didn’t go up to Camerino’s to help them can tomatoes. But why should she, since grandma, grandpa, Mary, Frank, and Joe are there to do it. They never come here to help Mom.”
Thursday, September 4: “God, is “he” hot again today. Mom went up-the-hill with Smutz to get tomatoes for canning. While she was gone “he” repeated to me everything “he” had said previously. According to “him” anything she canned will be poison for “him.” “He” added a few comments about his “limited” freedom and enjoyment here. “He” said he was cashing his bonds so he could have a good time – good bye my education. What’s more important, if she says anything, “I’ll cut her up and see that she makes the pages.””
The physical abuse did not materialize. The verbal abuse continued. I always felt he despised me from the beginning. It may well have started when I was a toddler and he thought I had replaced him, with my mother loving me more than she did him. They had dated for seven years before being married. During that time my mother had never met any of his family – not until a month or so before the wedding. They certainly had the time to get to know one another. On the other hand, I’m not sure he ever had the time to get to know me or I him.
In my eighteen years living in his presence, he never had a kind word for me. He never acknowledged any accomplishment I might have made. He never, to my recollection, hugged me or said he loved me. Many times, according to my diary entries, he did say: “No other husband treats his family so well. I must work all day to feed you. Without me, you would be scum.” He continued to begrudge everything we had and threatened to take everything we did have and leave, or, more preferable, to kick us out.
Earlier that year, soon after he bought our television set, given that all of our relatives and his friends already had one, he removed a tube or two and was pleased we now had a “broken tv.” His action was the result of my mother’s asking him to turn down the full-blast sound of the baseball game he was watching. He bragged to Uncle Bill and others that if he could not enjoy himself around the house, no one would.
His major form of having fun was gambling. It was not uncommon for him to end a fight with my mother by walking out of the house to play cards and lose hundreds of dollars in the process. On one occasion he did feel guilty about the gambling and that he had lost $57 two weeks ago and $20 last week. As penance he had gone to an auction in Pennsylvania and brought me a Helbros wristwatch. My diary says it had “17 jewels, gold stretch band, and sweep second hand. It was originally priced at $110 but he got it for $37. It is not second-hand or so he claims. Anyway it is not a bad looking watch and I rather like it.” It is, to my recollection, the only gift he ever bought for me. Birthday gifts and Christmas presents came from my mother.
Although my mother usually made me feel we were on the same side when either of us had arguments with “him,” she was not always warm and fuzzy. When it came to a decision that had to be made, her response was often: “Well, that’s your department, you can do what you think best; do what you want.” We seldom disagreed. Our own interactions were minimal and without physical touching, once I was out of childhood. The rare instance of our disagreements has only once referenced in my diary:
Sunday, December 14, 1952: “Sometimes I wonder just who the crazy one is around here. Him – Her – or Me. Right now, I am beginning to suspect it’s Her. The way she talks now, she can’t wait until I get out of here next year and go either to college or on my own.
“Well, I can’t wait either. Does she think I enjoy it around here with those two bitching all the time to each other and to me? Is it supposed to be fun to listen to her yell every time I come home about how rotten he is? I’m human – I can remember once and reason. I don’t have to learn by repetition like a dog.
“But who can I talk to? Whom can I confide in? No one. Certainly not to him or her. And I have no friends. So instead I have to keep it bottled up inside me. But it’s dangerous to let live steam condense of its own accord. Someday the safety valve has to pop.
“Anyway I can hardly wait until I can get out of this place and not return. I despise it and everything in it.”
So I admit that when stressed by the bickering and verbal/emotional abuse of my teen years, my response was often to sit on the porch swing in the summertime or retreat to my room at other times, where I would contemplate his death, my suicide or my hope that the future would be better once I was able to leave home for college.
It wasn’t until I was married, had my own family, and had enough instruction in psychology (in college I had as many “hours” in developmental psychology as I did in chemistry, my formal major) that I began to understand and appreciate my own development and the influence it had on me and how my own adult relationships arose from my younger life.
My father probably viewed me as the major competitor for my mother’s love for him. He took out his frustration and anger on both of us. They never saw divorce as a means of solving their problems, even though his brother Freemont (sic) had been divorced when his son, Fremont Junior, was in junior high school. It was then that Uncle Freemont became distanced from the family. Fremont was entirely outlawed, since he and his sister, Mary Ann, remained with his mother, Aunt Anne. It was only years later, after my father had died, and I became outlawed, that Fremont was reaccepted by the family. (Modern Italians still practice vendettas!)
During my college years and those which followed, I returned home only for Thanksgiving and Christmas. The love that he was unable to give to me, he wholeheartedly presented to his three grandchildren, especially on the very rare accessions when the two of them would visit us in the various parts of the country where we lived, at the time.
He and I spoke, sporadically; we never had a conversation, per se. I knew when I needed to walk away in order to avoid a complete argument. It was also during these later years that my mother and father seemed to have reached a more “livable” life. Without my presence, they appeared to go to more places with her relatives: Bill and Ada Moransky as well as Rose and Frank Borecki. I would hear about their trips to local fairs and shrines on weekends or for fish dinners on Fridays.
Over the years, my hated and loathing of how “He” treated me has been modified to an understanding of “Him.” I no longer hate him, but neither do I have a love of the father who was and never could be.